Welcome Middleton Insurance Company policy holders

Middleton Insurance Company has merged with Mt. Pleasant-Perry Mutual, effective January 1st, 2020.

Neighbor Insuring Neighbor Since 1876

Welcome to Mt. Pleasant-Perry Mutual Insurance, your local insurance company located in Monticello, Wisconsin. Unlike the bigger insurance companies, Mt. Pleasant-Perry Mutual Insurance strives to provide personal service close to home – Neighbor Insuring Neighbor. Learn more!

Mt. Pleasant-Perry Mutual Online Payment

Request A Quote

Mt. Pleasant – Perry Mutual has been providing economical insurance services for South Western and Central Wisconsin for 137 years. Our service area covers Adam, Juneau, Dodge, Grant, Lafayette, Green, Rock, Jefferson, Dane, Iowa, Richland, Sauk and Columbia Counties Wisconsin.   Mt. Pleasant – Perry Mutual wants to hear from you. Please fill out our Request Quote Form


Need homeowners insurance for your home? Mt. Pleasant-Perry Mutual provides free home insurance quotes to those our ten county southern Wisconsin area. We’ll give you a home insurance quote whether you own or rent your home; no matter what kind of home you have (house, condo, mobile home, or manufactured home). Need other insurance? We have you covered!

Our People

Our Agents are here to assist you in selecting an insurance policy which covers your needs. Home owners, farm owners, renters, commercial property, liability, mobile home and inland marine, we are here to help insure what is important in your life.

Business Hours

8:00 AM to 4:30 PM
Monday through Friday

Call, Fax, Email

Phone: 608-938-4008
Email: mppm@tds.net
Fax: 608-938-4018

Mail Us or Drop In

P.O. Box 38
306 East Lake Avenue.
Monticello, WI 53570